Pool score
3.5/10
Meta rating
88/100
Behind the numbers
How we scored this hotel
Two scores, two methods. The pool score is our editorial judgement of the pool itself. The meta rating is a weighted blend of every guest-rating source we track.
How the pool score is built
Five criteria, each rated 0–10, combined with fixed weights into a final 0–10 Pool Score.
3.5/10
| Criterion | Score | Weight |
|---|---|---|
Pool design & setting Architecture, materials, how the pool sits in the hotel | 2.5/10 | 25% |
View & atmosphere Skyline, sea, gardens, light, music, vibe | 5.0/10 | 25% |
Size & lounging space Pool dimensions, sunbeds, cabanas, deck space | 2.5/10 | 20% |
Access & seasonality Opening hours, season length, guest-only vs day-pass | 5.0/10 | 15% |
Service & maintenance Attendants, towels, food and drink, cleanliness | 2.5/10 | 15% |
How the meta rating is built
A weighted blend of every guest-rating source we track, normalized to a 0–100 scale.
88/100
| Source | Rating | Reviews | Weight | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.3★ | 714 | 58% | 50/100 | |
| TripAdvisor | 4.5★ | 5,279 | 42% | 38/100 |
Editor's note
The Dominick's rooftop pool offers a refreshing, though small, outdoor escape with views across the New York City skyline to New Jersey. While the pool area is generally pleasant, the limited wine selection at the pool bar detracts from the overall experience. Despite its seasonal nature, the rooftop setting provides a nice amenity.
Pool facts
Pool facts
- Pools
- 1
- Size
- Small (<50 m²)
- View
- Skyline
- Setting
- Rooftop · Outdoor
- Heated
- No
- Saltwater
- No
- Year-round
- No
- Season
- Summer
- Amenities
- Poolside food
- Adults only
- No
Only facts confirmed by 2+ sources or the hotel's own site are shown
What guests say about the pool
In their own words
The pool was a nice touch, but very smal
the pool area is nice but small. I was very disappointed in the bar at the pool. There is limited wine and the wine offered was HORRIBLE. The main bar had good wine so there is no reason that one could not get a good glass on the rooftop.
More condo/residence than hotel, this towering presence in SoHo offers rare rooftop poolside lounging and enviable square footage, wrapped in an air of confident solitude.
Gallery
More from the property
Photos via Google, TripAdvisor and the hotel's own website
Sources & verification
How we verified this pool
Last verified
Not yet verified — we are still checking this property.
Sources we used
Editorial review based on the hotel's own website, recent guest reviews on Google and TripAdvisor, and our notes from the property.
Affiliate disclosure: booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Rankings are editorial and not paid placements.